Provide structured, actionable design critiques using a comprehensive framework
Provide a structured design critique for [DESIGN WORK DESCRIPTION]. Design Context: - Design type: [UI/GRAPHIC/BRAND/PRODUCT] - Project stage: [CONCEPT/ITERATION/FINAL] - Goals: [WHAT THE DESIGN SHOULD ACHIEVE] - Constraints: [ANY LIMITATIONS] - Designer's concerns: [SPECIFIC FEEDBACK AREAS] Provide critique using this framework: **1. First Impressions (2 minutes)** - Initial emotional response - What stands out immediately - Overall clarity of communication - Gut feeling assessment **2. Alignment with Goals** - Does it achieve stated objectives? - Target audience appropriateness - Message clarity - Call-to-action effectiveness **3. Visual Design Analysis** *Hierarchy:* - Information prioritization - Visual weight distribution - Eye flow and scanning patterns *Composition:* - Balance and proportion - Use of space - Grid adherence - Alignment consistency *Color:* - Palette effectiveness - Contrast and readability - Emotional appropriateness - Accessibility compliance *Typography:* - Readability - Hierarchy clarity - Font choice appropriateness - Spacing and sizing **4. Strengths (What's Working)** - List 3-5 specific positive elements - Why they're effective - How they support goals **5. Opportunities (What Could Improve)** - List 3-5 specific areas for improvement - Why they're problematic - Specific suggestions for each **6. Questions for Clarification** - Intent questions - Constraint questions - Direction questions **7. Prioritized Action Items** | Priority | Issue | Recommendation | Effort | |----------|-------|----------------|--------| | High | | | | | Medium | | | | | Low | | | |
Provide a structured design critique for [DESIGN WORK DESCRIPTION]. Design Context: - Design type: [UI/GRAPHIC/BRAND/PRODUCT] - Project stage: [CONCEPT/ITERATION/FINAL] - Goals: [WHAT THE DESIGN SHOULD ACHIEVE] - Constraints: [ANY LIMITATIONS] - Designer's concerns: [SPECIFIC FEEDBACK AREAS] Provide critique using this framework: **1. First Impressions (2 minutes)** - Initial emotional response - What stands out immediately - Overall clarity of communication - Gut feeling assessment **2. Alignment with Goals** - Does it achieve stated objectives? - Target audience appropriateness - Message clarity - Call-to-action effectiveness **3. Visual Design Analysis** *Hierarchy:* - Information prioritization - Visual weight distribution - Eye flow and scanning patterns *Composition:* - Balance and proportion - Use of space - Grid adherence - Alignment consistency *Color:* - Palette effectiveness - Contrast and readability - Emotional appropriateness - Accessibility compliance *Typography:* - Readability - Hierarchy clarity - Font choice appropriateness - Spacing and sizing **4. Strengths (What's Working)** - List 3-5 specific positive elements - Why they're effective - How they support goals **5. Opportunities (What Could Improve)** - List 3-5 specific areas for improvement - Why they're problematic - Specific suggestions for each **6. Questions for Clarification** - Intent questions - Constraint questions - Direction questions **7. Prioritized Action Items** | Priority | Issue | Recommendation | Effort | |----------|-------|----------------|--------| | High | | | | | Medium | | | | | Low | | | |
This prompt is released under CC0 (Public Domain). You are free to use it for any purpose without attribution.
Explore similar prompts based on category and tags
Analyze UI layouts for hierarchy, balance, accessibility, and provide actionable improvements
Generate color palettes with theory explanations, accessibility compliance, and usage guidelines
Create detailed character design specifications for mascots, game characters, or brand illustrations
Create detailed icon set design specifications with grid systems, construction rules, and export requirements